Electronics World articles Popular Electronics articles QST articles Radio & TV News articles Radio-Craft articles Radio-Electronics articles Short Wave Craft articles Wireless World articles Google Search of RF Cafe website Sitemap Electronics Equations Mathematics Equations Equations physics Manufacturers & distributors LinkedIn Crosswords Engineering Humor Kirt's Cogitations RF Engineering Quizzes Notable Quotes Calculators Education Engineering Magazine Articles Engineering software RF Cafe Archives Magazine Sponsor Links Saturday Evening Post NEETS EW Radar Handbook Microwave Museum About RF Cafe Aegis Power Systems Alliance Test Equipment Centric RF Empower RF ISOTEC Reactel RF Connector Technology San Francisco Circuits Anritsu Amplifier Solutions Anatech Electronics Axiom Test Equipment Conduct RF Copper Mountain Technologies Exodus Advanced Communications Innovative Power Products KR Filters LadyBug Technologies Rigol TotalTemp Technologies Werbel Microwave Windfreak Technologies Wireless Telecom Group Withwave Resources Vintage Magazines RF Cafe Software WhoIs entry for RF Cafe.com Thank you for visiting RF Cafe!
Rigol DHO1000 Oscilloscope - RF Cafe

Copper Mountain Technologies (VNA) - RF Cafe

TotalTemp Technologies (Thermal Platforms) - RF Cafe

Please Support RF Cafe by purchasing my  ridiculously low−priced products, all of which I created.

RF Cascade Workbook for Excel

RF & Electronics Symbols for Visio

RF & Electronics Symbols for Office

RF & Electronics Stencils for Visio

RF Workbench

T-Shirts, Mugs, Cups, Ball Caps, Mouse Pads

These Are Available for Free

Espresso Engineering Workbook™

Smith Chart™ for Excel

LadyBug LB5954L Power Sensor with LAN Option - RF Cafe

Could Scientific American's "Skeptic" Be Wrong? - RF Cafe Forums

The original RF Cafe Forums were shut down in late 2012 due to maintenance issues - primarily having to spend time purging garbage posts from the board. At some point I might start the RF Cafe Forums again if the phpBB software gets better at filtering spam.

Below are the old forum threads, including responses to the original posts.

-- Amateur Radio
-- Anecdotes, Gripes & Humor
-- Antennas
-- CAE, CAD, & Software
-- Circuits & Components
-- Employment & Interviews
-- Miscellany
-- Swap Shop
-- Systems
-- Test & Measurement
-- Webmaster

Kirt Blattenberger
 Post subject: Could Scientific American's "Skeptic" Be Wrong?
Posted: Wed Jan 03, 2007 11:23 pm 
 
Site Admin
User avatar

Joined: Sun Aug 03, 2003 2:02 pm
Posts: 878
Location: Erie, PA
Greetings:

Scientific American has lots of good articles, and I have read through just about every edition for the last 20-some years (not every article, of course). Most of the columnists I enjoy reading, especially Steve Mirsky, writer of the "Antigravity" column. His humor is always sure to make me chuckle.

On the other hand, Michael Shermer, writer of the "Skeptic" column, is always pretentious and insulting with his writings. Somehow, he manages to assail Creationists in almost every article, regardless of what the topic happens to be. Regardless of your opinion on Creationism vs. Evolution, having to read the vile hatred begin spewed each month gets tiresome. The columns could be very interesting otherwise. He always sets himself up as above reproach on every issue. Well, I might have found a chink in his armor in the November 2006 issue.

In the article, he addresses the record of some scientists being "wronger than wrong" throughout history, and correctly points out that as time goes on, the wrongness of those people become more and more apparent. He quotes Asimov as writing, "When people thought the earth was flat, they were wrong. When people though the earth was spherical, they were wrong. But if you that thinking the earth is round is just as wrong as thinking the earth is flat, then your view is wronger than wrong." In fact, the earth is an oblate spheroid, which is much closer to a sphere than it is to a plane.

Where Mr. Shermer errs, in my observation, is when he writes, "Scientists' wrongness attenuates with time." I believe that in the context of the article he intends exactly the opposite of attenuation: amplification. Indeed, wrongness is amplified with time as more knowledge is gained.

Here's a link to the article in case you're interested.

http://sciam.com/article.cfm?chanID=sa006&articleID=00028C98-6F5C-152E-A9F183414B7F0000&pageNumber=1&catID=2

_________________
- Kirt Blattenberger :smt024
RF Cafe Progenitor & Webmaster





Posted  11/12/2012
LadyBug LB5954L Power Sensor with LAN Option - RF Cafe
Noisecom

Anatech Electronics RF Microwave Filters - RF Cafe

Exodus Advanced Communications Best in Class RF Amplifier SSPAs