Electronics World articles Popular Electronics articles QST articles Radio & TV News articles Radio-Craft articles Radio-Electronics articles Short Wave Craft articles Wireless World articles Google Search of RF Cafe website Sitemap Electronics Equations Mathematics Equations Equations physics Manufacturers & distributors LinkedIn Crosswords Engineering Humor Kirt's Cogitations RF Engineering Quizzes Notable Quotes Calculators Education Engineering Magazine Articles Engineering software RF Cafe Archives Magazine Sponsor Links Saturday Evening Post NEETS EW Radar Handbook Microwave Museum About RF Cafe Aegis Power Systems Alliance Test Equipment Centric RF Empower RF ISOTEC Reactel RF Connector Technology San Francisco Circuits Anritsu Amplifier Solutions Anatech Electronics Axiom Test Equipment Conduct RF Copper Mountain Technologies Exodus Advanced Communications Innovative Power Products KR Filters LadyBug Technologies Rigol TotalTemp Technologies Werbel Microwave Windfreak Technologies Wireless Telecom Group Withwave Resources Vintage Magazines RF Cafe Software WhoIs entry for RF Cafe.com Thank you for visiting RF Cafe!
Innovative Power Products Passive RF Products - RF Cafe

Noisecom

Anritsu Test Equipment - RF Cafe

Please Support RF Cafe by purchasing my  ridiculously low-priced products, all of which I created.

RF Cascade Workbook for Excel

RF & Electronics Symbols for Visio

RF & Electronics Symbols for Office

RF & Electronics Stencils for Visio

RF Workbench

T-Shirts, Mugs, Cups, Ball Caps, Mouse Pads

These Are Available for Free

Espresso Engineering Workbook™

Smith Chart™ for Excel

Rigol DHO1000 Oscilloscope - RF Cafe

The "Monty Hall Paradox" - RF Cafe Forums

The original RF Cafe Forums were shut down in late 2012 due to maintenance issues - primarily having to spend time purging garbage posts from the board. At some point I might start the RF Cafe Forums again if the phpBB software gets better at filtering spam.

Below are the old forum threads, including responses to the original posts.

-- Amateur Radio
-- Anecdotes, Gripes & Humor
-- Antennas
-- CAE, CAD, & Software
-- Circuits & Components
-- Employment & Interviews
-- Miscellany
-- Swap Shop
-- Systems
-- Test & Measurement
-- Webmaster

Kirt Blattenberger
 Post subject: The "Monty Hall Paradox"
Posted: Fri Mar 09, 2012 7:53 pm 
 
Site Admin
User avatar

Joined: Sun Aug 03, 2003 2:02 pm
Posts: 451
Location: Erie, PA
The "Monty Hall Paradox"

Image

Most of us have taken at least one statistics course. The calculated results of most exercises usually jibed with expected result. The famous "Monty Hall Paradox" involving whether the contestant should switch doors after the first opened door is shown to contain a goat. Should the player stick with his original door, or change to the remaining unopened door in order to improve his chances of winning? PhDs have argued philosophy vs. mathematics over the situation. Here is an online applet that demonstrates the possibly surprising best choice. I say based on evolving conditions, the best answer is 50/50. You?

http://www.letsmakeadeal.com

_________________
- Kirt Blattenberger :smt024
RF Cafe Progenitor & Webmaster


 
   
 
SunshineDesign
 Post subject: Re: The "Monty Hall Paradox"
Posted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 11:35 pm 
 
Captain

Joined: Sat Nov 08, 2008 11:35 pm
Posts: 6
Location: Ramona, CA
It is always best choice to change your selection after the first wrong choice. This is based on mathematics and statistics.

_________________
Sunshine Design Engineering Services


 
   
 
Clay
 Post subject: Re: The "Monty Hall Paradox"
Posted: Wed Mar 14, 2012 3:01 pm 
 
Lieutenant
User avatar

Joined: Tue Feb 16, 2010 4:02 pm
Posts: 4
Location: Ontario, Canada
I saw one of 'The Mythbusters' shows the other night with the 3 door paradox. They decided that
changing your first choice was best. I'll go with Kirt and say 50-50. There were not enough
random samples for critical analysis. Flip an unbiased coin 10E6 times and still get 50-50.
Just my 2 cents worth.
Best regards,
/Clay


 
   
 
SunshineDesign
 Post subject: Re: The "Monty Hall Paradox"
Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2012 2:32 am 
 
Captain

Joined: Sat Nov 08, 2008 11:35 pm
Posts: 6
Location: Ramona, CA
Here are 2 articles that may help analyze the problem and provides some insight
why peoples' intuition get this wrong and why the better choice is to switch choice,
if you get the first choice wrong.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem
http://saliu.com/monty-paradox.html

Enjoy the reading. If Game Theory interests you, I just finished an excellant read in
Bruce Bueno de Mesquita's "The Predictioneer's Game". It is a facinating read on Game
Theory and how "predictions" can be made of people choices as Bruce book states
"Using the Logic of Brazen Self-Interest to See and Shape the Future." They had a
show on Bruce's work 2 years ago on TV. The US Govenrment State Depatrment and
CIA has rated Bruce's prediction of world political and other events at better than 90%.
This is increadible statistics on future predictioneering.

_________________
Sunshine Design Engineering Services


 
   
 
Clay
 Post subject: Re: The "Monty Hall Paradox"
Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2012 4:45 pm 
 
Lieutenant
User avatar

Joined: Tue Feb 16, 2010 4:02 pm
Posts: 4
Location: Ontario, Canada
Thanks for those links, very interesting.
How the paradox is stated seems to matter as well.
Best regards,
/Clay


 
   
 Post subject: Re: The "Monty Hall Paradox"Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2012 4:45 pm 
tsiros
 
 
Lieutenant

Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2012 8:22 am
Posts: 2
all this with the (possibly false) assumption that the room contents do not change after the first door has been chosen. The assumption holds, when doing a purely theoretical analysis of the situation (based on game theory/statistics) but i would be hesitant to apply the results on a tv game-show. Although a goat might be of some use here in greece now with the recession and all.

greetings to all!





Posted  11/12/2012
Rigol DHO1000 Oscilloscope - RF Cafe
LadyBug RF Power Sensors

Exodus Advanced Communications Best in Class RF Amplifier SSPAs

RF Electronics Shapes, Stencils for Office, Visio by RF Cafe